CZECHOSLOVAK NORMALISATION VS. CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL MEDIA: IDENTIFYING THE IDEOLOGICAL DISCOURSE MARKERS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17721/if.54.23.13Keywords:
translation historiography; normalisation; paratext; social media; ideology; propagandaAbstract
Background. Czechoslovakia belonged among the countries that fell into the sphere of the Soviet influence in the wake of WW2. In the Eastern Bloc, all aspects of public life were controlled by state institutions, including literature and publishing. This paper consists of two parts. Firstly, it presents research dealing with the literary paratexts pertaining to fiction translated from English into Slovak and published during the normalisation period. The goal was to explore the ideological discourse in the selected material and identify Soviet propaganda. Secondly, it explains how the same methodology can be used to identify contemporary Russian propaganda on the Internet.
Methods. This paper combines translation historiography and material research. In the first part, discourse analysis was performed on 100 samples of paratexts. The method of analysing ideological discourse markers is subsequently transposed to a new context, i.e., contemporary propaganda on the Slovak social media with the purpose to illustrate how current Russian propaganda affects not only the virtual environment, but also physical reality in Slovakia.
Results. The presence of ideological markers in the normalisation paratexts peaked in 1977, which correlates with Charter 77, an informal civic initiative against normalisation practices. The results of the second part of the presented research show that contemporary Russia successfully uses the same persuasion techniques as during the existence of the Soviet Union. The content found in the samples can be easily traced back to the “alternative” media outlets, some of them demonstrably funded by Russia. However, in the online era, dissemination of false information and propaganda is much faster, which poses a global security risk for democracy and human rights.
Conclusions. As the Globsec survey (Szekers 2021) has shown, Slovakia is the most vulnerable EU country when it comes to falling for disinformation. The presented method of ideological discourse marker analysis could be helpful in terms of propaganda identification. The Internet requires a completely new skillset to sift through the vast amount of information that may or may not be credible.
References
Allport, G. (1949). The Nature of Prejudice. Addison-Wesley. https://faculty.washington.edu/caporaso/courses/203/readings/allport_Nature_of_prejudice.pdf.
Bachledová, M. (2017). Ideológia v paratextoch k prekladovej literatúre 1968 – 1989. Banská Bystrica : Belianum.
Bachledová, M. (2021). Translators and Publishers in Czechoslovakia (1968-1989): Following and Subverting the Ideology. In M. Djovčoš, E. Perez, and M. Kusá (Eds.), Translation, Interpreting and Culture. Old Dogmas, New Approaches (pp.17–42). Peter Lang. DOI 10.3726/b18335
Betts, R. R. (1945). The European Satellite States: Their War Contribution and Present Position. International Affairs, 21 (1), 15–29. DOI:10.2307/3018989.
Breiner, V. (2023, November 23). Šéf SIS: Ruskí diplomati financujú alternatívne médiá. Infosecurity.sk. https://infosecurity.sk/dezinfo/sef-sis-ruski-diplomati-financuju-alternativne-media/.
CHO/Czech News Agency. (2017, May 30). Odhalenie nemeckej televízie: Kotlebovci dostávali peniaze od prokremeľského podnikateľa. Hospodárske noviny. https://hnonline.sk/svet/969022-odhalenie-nemeckej-televizie-kotlebovci-dostavali-peniaze-od-prokremelskeho-podnikatela.
Dinič, D. (2022, 10 February). Proruskí dezinformační aktéri útočia na Európsku úniu, nechýbajú ani tvrdenia o fašizme v Bruseli. Infosecurity.sk. https://infosecurity.sk/dezinfo/proruski-dezinformacni-akteri-utocia-na-europsku-uniu-nechybaju-ani-tvrdenia-o-fasizme-v-bruseli-infosecurity-sk-bi-weekly-report-o-nastupujucich-dezinformacnych-trendoch-30-september-2022/
Drábik, J. (2019) Fašizmus. Premedia.
Fifth Column. Encyclopaedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/fifth-column.
Glanc, T. (2020) Normalizace rusistiky na Filozofické fakultě Univerzity Karlovy. In SLOVO A SMYSL 2020 (17) 35. https://wordandsense.ff.cuni.cz/en/2020-3-8/.
Griffin, R. (1993). The Nature of Fascism. Taylor & Francis Ltd.
Hanzel, M. (2023, 2 April) Ukrajina plánuje s Krymom VEĽKÉ veci: Demontujú most, vysťahujú Rusov a to nie je VŠETKO! DNES24.sk. https://www.dnes24.sk/ukrajina-planuje-s-krymom-velke-veci-demontuju-most-vystahuju-rusov-a-to-nie-je-vsetko-431813?fbclid=IwAR1bvcyMhiRCfYEakh1Zk3QIH2dcQFLbB0C3GekDPMbWSD_ALLoRkAgE1KU
Hruboй, A, Lepiš, J., Tokárová, Z. (eds). (2012). Slovensko v rokoch neslobody 1938 – 1989. Ústav pamäti národa.
Hutko, D. (2023, September 1). Mobilizácia do vojny proti Rusku? Panika, ktorú toto klamstvo vyvolalo, je prácou ziskuchtivých podvodníkov. Pravda. https://spravy.pravda.sk/domace/clanok/653037-mobilizacia-do-vojny-proti-rusku-panika-ktoru-toto-klamstvo-vyvolalo-je-pracou-ziskuchtivych-podvodnikov/
Jareš, J., Spurný, M., Volná, K. et al. (2012). Náměstí krasnoarmějcú 2. Učitelé a student na Filozofické fakultě UK v období normalizace. Filozofická fakulta UK – Togga, 2012.
Kačmárik, R. (2022, 28 January). Anticharta: Keď umelci poslúžili režimu. Pravda. https://kultura.pravda.sk/na-citanie/clanok/614929-anticharta-ked-umelci-posluzili-rezimu/.
Katuška, M. (2022, 8 April). Slovensko poslalo na Ukrajinu systém S-300. Takto zatiaľ nepomohla žiadna Krajina. SME.sk. https://domov.sme.sk/c/22881051/slovensko-poslalo-na-ukrajinu-system-s-300-takto-zatial-ukrajine-nepomohla-ziadna-krajina.html.
Klynveld Peat Marwick Goerdeler (KPMG). Economy Key facts Germany as of March 2023. https://kpmg.com/de/en/home/insights/overview/economic-key-facts-germany.html).
Kořínek, O. (2006). Pozývací list 1968. Albert Marenčin – Vydavateľstvo PT.
Kosatík, P. (2016). Češi 1977: Jak z rock'n'rollu vznikla Charta 77. Mladá fronta.
Kováč, P. (2022, 5 April). Kotlebu odsúdili, do väzenia však nepôjde. SME. Available at: https://domov.sme.sk/c/22877985/kotlebu-odsudili-do-vazenia-nepojde.html
Liberalism. Encyclopaedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/liberalism.
Madro, P. (2023, 23 February).Tvrdia, že chcú mier. Ich pochody sú však hlásnou trúbou Putina. Pravda. https://spravy.pravda.sk/domace/clanok/658161-tvrdia-ze-chcu-mier-ich-pochody-su-vsak-hlasnou-trubou-putina/
Magová, G., Passia, R. (2015). Deväť životov prekladateľa. Rozhovory o preklade a literárnom živote. Kalligram.
Mesežnikov, G. (2022, 9 June). Slovak Disinformation Scene at the End of the Year 2021. Visegrad Insight. https://visegradinsight.eu/slovak-disinformation-media-2021/.
Ministry of Defence of the Slovak Republic. Dohoda o spolupráci v oblasti obrany medzi vládou Slovenskej republiky a vládou Spojených štátov amerických. https://www.mosr.sk/dohoda-o-spolupraci-v-oblasti-obrany-medzi-vladou-slovenskej-republiky-a-vladou-spojenych-statov-americkych/.
Ministry of Defence of the Slovak Republic. (2023, 25 March). Patriot Air Defence System at Sliač is Ready, Air Defences Are To Be Boosted On Slovakia's Eastern Border As Well. (Press report). https://www.mosr.sk/51253-en/system-patriot-na-sliaci-je-pripraveny-aj-na-vychodnej-hranici-posilnime-protivzdusnu-obranu/.
Moulis, V. (2006). Neobyčejný život Nikity Sergejeviče. Dokořán.
Navara, L. (2009, 3 January). Abeceda komunistických zločinů: Od „androše“ k Asanaci. iDnes. https://www.idnes.cz/zpravy/domaci/abeceda-komunistickych-zlocinu-od-androse-k-asanaci.A090102_155231_domaci_ton.
Osvaldová, L. (2022, September 1). Dvakrát odsúdený Kotlebov podpredseda Medvecký môže byť poslancom, aj keď zbil človeka a šoféroval opitý. DenníkN. https://dennikn.sk/1703570/dvakrat-odsudeny-kotlebov-krajsky-predseda-medvecky-moze-byt-poslancom-aj-ked-zbil-cloveka-a-soferoval-opity/.
Oxford Languages. https://languages.oup.com/google-dictionary-en/
Popper, K. (1945/2012). The Open Society and Its Enemies. Routledge.
Prando, P., Šuša, I. (2011). Taliansko. Vybrané kapitoly z politiky, straníckeho systému a politickej komunikácie. Banská Bystrica : FPV UMB.
Rachůnková, Z. (1992). Zamlčovaní překladatelé. Bibliografie 1948 –1989. Obec prekladatelu.
Rubáš, S. et al. (2012). Slovo za slovem. S překládateli o překládání. Academia, 2012.
SITA – Slovak Press Agency. (2022, 16 September). Väčšina Slovákov by prijala v čele krajiny niekoho ako je Orbán, aký typ voličov preferuje autoritárskeho lídra? Webnoviny. https://www.webnoviny.sk/vacsina-slovakov-by-prijala-v-cele-krajiny-niekoho-ako-je-orban-aky-typ-volicov-preferuje-autoritarskeho-lidra/
Stråth. B. (2013). Ideology and conceptual history. In Freeden M., Stears M. (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of political ideologies (pp. 15–36). Oxford University Press.
Szekers, E. (2021, 5 August). Slovakia grapples with the ‘big business’ of disinformation. Balkan Insight. https://balkaninsight.com/2021/08/05/slovakia-grapples-with-the-big-business-of-disinformation/
TASR (Slovak Press Agency). (2023, 19 January). Primátorka Sliača: Referendum bolo v súlade so zákonom, nenamieta to ani prokuratúra. https://myzvolen.sme.sk/c/23115941/primatorka-sliaca-referendum-bolo-v-sulade-so-zakonom-nenamieta-to-ani-prokuratura.html.
Tyšš, I. (2017a) Discourse camouflage in the representation of American literature in the literary magazine Mladá tvorba World Literature Studies 2, vol. 9, 73–85.
Tyšš, I. (2017b) Teoretické a materiálové sondy do praxeológie a dejín prekladu americkej literatúry na Slovensku v období socializmu. Mladá tvorba a Beat Generation. UKF FF.
Van Dijk, T. A. (2006). Ideology and discourse analysis. Journal of Political Ideologies. 11(2006), 115–140.
Verschueren, J. (2012). Ideology in Language Use. Cambridge University Press.
Zmigrod, L. (2022.) A Psychology of Ideology: Unpacking the Psychological Structure of Ideological Thinking. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 17(4), 1072–1092. DOI: 10.1177/17456916211044140.